Model X vs Model Y: A Comparison for Electric SUV Buyers

By contrast, the Model Y opts for a minimalist and practical design. It features a single 15-inch touchscreen that controls nearly every function, clean interior lines, and quality materials that reflect improved build quality. Buyers can choose between a five- or a seven-seat model, and this seating configuration directly affects interior space, passenger capacity, and cargo versatility, allowing the Model Y to adapt to different needs for families or commuters.

Winner: Model X for luxury design and premium feel, Model Y for practicality and simplicity.

Performance and Range

Performance is one of Tesla’s greatest advantages, and both models deliver exhilarating speed and range. The Model X is capable of impressive acceleration, achieving high top speeds, and towing significant weight, making it a highly versatile SUV.

• Model X Long Range: 670 horsepower, 0–60 mph in 3.5 seconds, top speed 155 mph.

• Model X Plaid Edition: 1,020 horsepower, 0–60 mph in 2.5 seconds, top speed 149 mph.

• Model Y Performance (Y Performance): Around 455 horsepower, 0–60 mph in 3.5 seconds, top speed 155 mph.

When it comes to driving range, the Model Y Long Range variant can travel up to 337 miles per charge, slightly outperforming the Model X Long Range, which reaches around 335 miles.

For those who prioritize faster home charging, the Lectron Portable Level 2 Tesla EV Charger (240V, 40A) delivers up to 9.6 kW of power, adding roughly 36 miles of range per hour. It includes WiFi-enabled control and NACS compatibility for Tesla and other electric vehicles.

Winner: Model X for power and acceleration, Model Y for better range and efficiency.

Features and Technology

Both Tesla models are equipped with impressive features that make daily driving safe, convenient, and enjoyable. The Model X leads in luxury technology with a 17-inch infotainment system, a second touchscreen for rear passengers, and a 22-speaker premium audio setup.

The Model Y includes Tesla’s signature 15-inch central display, which provides seamless access to entertainment, navigation, and vehicle controls. Both vehicles offer Enhanced Autopilot, adaptive cruise control, and Tesla’s advanced driver-assistance system for highway driving.

The Model Y's 15-inch central display. Image courtesy of EV Help Hub.

Comfort features include heated seats, heated steering wheel, and optional ventilated front seats. Tesla also integrates bioweapon defense mode, a high-efficiency HEPA filtration system that purifies cabin air and enhances overall comfort.

Winner: Model X for high-end technology, Model Y for straightforward usability.

Space and Practicality

For families, space is one of the main deciding factors in the Model X vs Model Y debate. The Model X provides up to 92.3 cubic feet of cargo space, making it one of the roomiest SUVs in the electric segment. One important point is that the Model X offers multiple seating options, including three rows for up to seven passengers, allowing for flexible configurations based on your needs. The rear seats fold flat to accommodate large luggage or sports gear.

The Model X boasts up to 92.3 cubic feet of cargo space. Image courtesy of Carwow.

The Model Y offers a total of 76.2 cubic feet of cargo space with the seats folded down. While its third-row option is more compact, it remains a useful feature for families with children. Both vehicles provide split-folding second-row seats for flexible storage and convenience.

For outdoor enthusiasts, the Model X also includes a roof rack option for carrying bikes or kayaks, further enhancing its practicality.

Winner: Model X for total space, Model Y for urban versatility.

Dimensions and Towing

The Tesla Model X is larger in every dimension, offering a longer wheelbase and wider stance. This results in improved stability and towing power, giving it a towing capacity of up to 4,960 pounds.

The Model X towing a camper van. Image courtesy of InsideEVs.

The Model Y can tow up to 3,500 pounds, which is sufficient for smaller trailers or recreational gear. Both vehicles benefit from instant torque provided by the dual motor system, making towing smooth and consistent even on inclines.

Winner: Model X for towing and road presence.

Reliability and Maintenance

According to J.D. Power’s latest ratings, the Model X scores 71 out of 100 in reliability, while the Model Y follows closely with 69 out of 100. Both the Model X and Model Y come with a four-year or 50,000-mile limited warranty and an eight-year battery and drive unit warranty.

Image courtesy of Business Insider.

Maintenance requirements are minimal since electric vehicles have fewer moving parts than gas-powered cars. Owners mainly need to focus on tire rotation, cabin air filter replacement, and software updates.

To simplify home charging, the Lectron Home Level 2 NACS Tesla V-BOX Pro is a great addition for any Tesla owner. It supports up to 48 amps for fast charging, WiFi scheduling, and can be plugged or hardwired for maximum flexibility.

Winner: Model X with a slight edge for long-term reliability and coverage.

Price and Value

Price is often the deciding factor for most buyers. The Tesla Model Y starts at $44,990, while the Model X begins at $84,990 before add-ons. The Plaid Model X can exceed $100,000 with options, but its unmatched acceleration and luxury justify the premium for those seeking top performance.

The Model Y remains the more affordable option, offering nearly the same technology, range, and safety as the Model X for almost half the cost.

Winner: Model Y for value and efficiency.

Driving Experience

When it comes to the driving experience, both the Tesla Model X and Model Y deliver the signature smoothness and quietness that electric vehicles are known for. The Tesla Model X stands out with its Falcon wing rear doors, which not only add a dramatic flair but also enhance the sense of luxury every time you step inside. Behind the wheel, the Model X—especially in the Plaid model—offers breathtaking acceleration and more power than most SUVs on the road, making every drive feel exhilarating. The tri-motor Plaid edition rockets from 0 to 60 mph in just 2.5 seconds, setting a new standard for electric SUV performance.

In contrast, the Model Y provides a more compact and nimble driving experience, ideal for city streets and tight parking spaces. Its dual motor setup ensures confident all-wheel drive traction and responsive handling, while still delivering impressive speed and acceleration. Both the Model X and Model Y come equipped with advanced features like adaptive cruise control and a heated steering wheel, making long journeys more comfortable and stress-free. Whether you crave the commanding presence and speed of the Model X or the agile efficiency of the Model Y, both Tesla models offer a driving experience that’s a cut above traditional SUVs.

Environmental Benefits

Choosing a Tesla Model X or Model Y isn’t just about performance and technology—it’s also a step toward a cleaner, greener future. Both models are fully electric vehicles, meaning they produce zero tailpipe emissions and help reduce air pollution in your community. By driving a Tesla, you’re directly contributing to lower greenhouse gas emissions and supporting the shift away from fossil fuels.

Electric vehicles like the Model X and Model Y are also far more energy-efficient than traditional gas-powered cars. While gasoline engines only convert about 20% of their fuel’s energy into motion, Tesla’s electric powertrains deliver 60-70% efficiency from the grid to the wheels. This means more of the energy you use actually goes into powering your vehicle, making every mile cleaner and more sustainable. As more drivers make the switch to electric vehicles, the environmental advantage of Tesla models becomes even more significant, helping to pave the way for a healthier planet.

Electric Vehicle Market

The electric vehicle market is experiencing rapid growth, and Tesla remains at the forefront with its innovative lineup of electric SUVs and cars. The Model X, with its blend of luxury features, advanced technology, and impressive range, appeals to buyers seeking a high-end electric SUV that doesn’t compromise on performance or comfort. Meanwhile, the Model Y has quickly become a favorite among those looking for a more affordable option that still offers the benefits of a Tesla—long range, cutting-edge features, and the versatility of an SUV.

As electric vehicles become more mainstream, both the Model X and Model Y

Comparison Summary

Both Tesla models represent the future of electric SUVs, offering a mix of speed, safety, and sustainability. The Model X stands as the ultimate choice for those who value space, three rows of seating, and luxurious features. However, buyers interested in the Model X should be aware that there may be waiting periods due to high demand and production delays. The Model Y, however, appeals to most buyers who want a stylish, efficient, and affordable option that still delivers Tesla’s signature performance.

Tesla Model X vs Model Y: Key Specs